What to do about McFadden?

I am in a 16 team league where we keep 3. Right now, my 3 keepers are portis, Ronnie Brown, and Jennings. This team was not very good last year, so I have the 3rd pick in a nonsnake order draft. However, one team ended up stacked (don't ask me how, I joined in the offseason) and they have Mcgahee, Addai, Lynch, Wayne, ocho, Housh, Earnest Graham, Reggie Bush, and TO. The first 5 are the ones he is choosing between. Where does Mcfadden go in all of this?